Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material #3

Over the past few weeks, we've been doing a variety of class activities, such as the "photo and describe" ones. To do these, we had to pick a photo as a class and describe it without using the word we chose that was fit to describing the photo. For me, it was actually a pretty hard task. Personally, I feel like I lack a sense of creativity needed to formulate elaborate sentences that describe a photo without just using a bunch of adjectives. As a class, I don't think we really enjoyed it either. We just seemed to disagree on which photo to choose, and then we disagreed on what word to choose, and not everyone participated making the whole thing that much harder to finish. However, we did an even harder activity which I call the "car crash activity" because we had to come up with something sad/tragic (like a car crash) and then describe the subject before actually naming the subject. It was pretty funny when our sad/tragic event was going to a friend's house only to discover that they don't remember the password to their wifi, something I feel that our generation takes very seriously. Although it was really funny, it was actually really hard to come up with adjectives to describe that situation and how it makes you feel. I also feel like the class didn't really understand what we supposed to do, and at the end we eventually came up with, I think a four-word sentence that was just incredibly awful. I think we should try revisiting that activity though, because I'd like to give another shot at it. Clearly it was of importance to know how to do it, and I feel like we didn't leave it off on a good note.

Other than that, we've basically been doing Hamlet, probably my favorite Shakespeare play that I've read so far. Personally, I find it incredibly helpful when Ms. Holmes butts in and explains what just happened/is about to happen, what specific words/phrases mean, and other general things--they've helped me get started on my annotations! What I find most strange about the play is Shakespeare's writing. Did people really talk that way in the Elizabethan Era? It all seems a little grandiose to me, and I seriously can't imagine people speaking that way. However, I do realize this is all written in the 1600s so of course diction and other speaking elements are different, it's just hard for me to believe sometimes.  Another thing that kind of bothers me is why can't any of the characters just say what's on their mind??? It's totally a motif and Shakespeare probably did it on purpose, but I just know that if people  understood what each other were saying, the whole play would be resolved so quickly. In Act 1, Scene 2 Hamlet threatens to kill himself and the King and Queen don't get it at all. In Act 2, Scene 2 Hamlet basically tells Polonius about Ophelia's and his relationship, but refers to himself as the "sun" and Ophelia as a "dog" so, naturally, Polonius doesn't understand. Lastly, in Act 4, Scene 5 Ophelia tells everyone in the room all these details of her and Hamlet's relationship but nobody, yet again, understands. Maybe they do and don't care? Maybe they're all just really stupid? I don't know, but it really bothers me when conflicts can be resolved quickly and thoroughly but they aren't.

Another element of Shakespeare's writing that confuses me is his use of absolute simplistic writing tools, like the whole pirate scene. He used a totally random situation simply for bringing Hamlet back into the play. Personally, I think I just gave Shakespeare too much credit for being this really elaborate, intelligent and witty guy that such an uncomplicated transition kind of disappointed me. Overall, Hamlet is definitely a play unlike any other I've read and I'm excited that I've finally found a play by Shakespeare that I enjoy.

5 comments:

  1. Nice response, Helle! Very thoughtful. I love the way you described Willy's life as "an uphill battle between his reality and his hopes". That really captures the essence of his struggle and justifies the overwhelming feeling of exhaustion that he experiences throughout the play. However, I have to disagree with your claim that Salesman's meaning is readily apparent and easy to uncover in comparison with the rest of the American canon. Personally, I found Miller's play to often be quite contradictory and at times, extremely complex. The clash of intense emotions in the play makes it difficult to pick out a concrete message or meaning. You also identified a unique link between the Miller's characterization and the development of meaning in the play, which I think is an apt observation. Do you have any examples of this? It would be interesting to see which characters you believe connect with which motifs. Nice job, Helle!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Helle, You have really in depth discussion and analysis of Death of a Salesman and this is great. The discussion you have about whether Miller’s DOS is truly a tragedy is great and really interesting, but this would fall into the previous response to course material that we did not this one. You also need to include the other things we have covered in class such as the closed prompt we wrote in class to The Century Quilt, mood and atmosphere exercises, and Hamlet. While DOS may have been the focus for a long time in class we finished discussions and our summary and analysis and moved on to other topics that you should include in your response to course material. This is really good analysis of DOS though.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Helle,
    I wrote my peer reviews last week and am just posting them today. I guess my feedback isn't very useful because you have already fixed the things I commented on. Sorry.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey Helle,
    I feel the same about the activity of trying to describe a moment captured by a picture and trying to describe it without any adjectives, because i too lack a little in creativity and compared to the other students. Although i did think that we did a great job of completing the first picture description, as for the second about the anger men, i didn't think, we did so well on, maybe it was because of the lack of focus. As for the course materials, i did find that you had left out some things we had done in class. Like the closed prompted about the "The Century Quilt" what did you think of it? Did you like it? How did you do the second time we rewrote the essay? What about the things Ms.Holmes pointed out for us?

    ReplyDelete