For this particular Close Reading, I read an article titled "Give Affordable Care Act a Chance" which gave me a clear understanding of which side the author was on right off the bat. Using language, details, and diction the author does not successfully describes the issue of "Obamacare" and what he/she thinks about it, rather it sometimes contradicts what is said in the title of the article.
Beginning the article, the author states the failure of the Affordable Care Act, saying "The website roll-out is a disaster, and part of the sales pitch amounted to a bait and switch" but then continues on to defend the act and it's promises of delivering health care to the American people, regardless of what he/she said only a sentence before. This language made it unclear as to what the author was basing her opinion on. His/Her language was contradicting, which is not what should happen in an editorial. I feel that, if one is going to write an opinion-based article, they should stick with their main opinion and back it up with evidence. Continually throughout the essay, the author goes from side to side, first offering that Obama should never have promised the American people that they could keep their health care plan, only to say that the citizens who attack this clear mistake on the President's behalf are unwarranted and "often proven inaccurate". This language makes it impossible to understand what the author is trying to make a point of. However, the author does employ a hopeful tone in the language she uses in the first paragraph. Calling the health care act a "disaster" only to say, "it's on that promise [of delivering health insurance to all citizens] that it's success will be judged" shows that he/she believes that although multiple, disastrous issues have birthed from the Affordable Care Act, it will come out shining in the end. This language makes me feel that the author has hope for the eventual outcome of "Obamacare".
The authors details offer little to nothing as to what he/she thinks about the issue they are talking about, as well. Stating that "The Affordable Care Act is grounded in the proposition that all Americans should have access to adequate health coverage at an affordable price" gives the idea that the author believes, like said in the title, that the health care act should be given another chance. However, in the next paragraph, he/she states that, "A significant number of customers who are buying insurance on their own do not have plans of that quality"-a detail that completely contradicts what he/she said in the previous paragraph. The author's use of details does not adequately cover what they think about the issue, hardly making it an editorial.
Finally, the diction employed by the author further proves how undeveloped their opinion on the issue of "Obamacare" is. Calling it a "disaster" in the beginning, to a great "help" in the final contradicts her main point. He/She does make it clear how they feel about the health care act, but with continuous contradictions, it makes it hard to believe that the author actually believes what they say they do. He/She calls the law "messy" as well, only to say "think about the mess the law is designed to address" again making it hard to be on the author's side if they keep bringing up the faults of the health care act. In general, the diction of this piece makes it seem as though the author is against the Affordable Care Act, but his/her language offers a different perspective.
In general, the author of this editorial did poorly in displaying their opinion on "Obamacare" through their poor choice in language, details, and diction. Contradicting language, detail, and diction all made it unclear as to where the author stood and did not make it a very moving editorial.
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20131104/OPINION01/311040005/Editorial-roundup-Give-Affordable-Care-Act-chance?nclick_check=1
Way to read closely, Helle! So you chose an article with a rather weak voice to analyze this time, and my understanding of this assignment was that we were supposed to find an opinion piece that has a particularly strong voice, and then identify how the author establishes that voice using literary techniques. You make up for it with your thoughtful analysis of the authors use of language, details and diction in your body paragraphs, though! So no harm done. Just something to think about for next time. At the risk of being overly critical, I also noticed that you didn't include a clear thesis statement. Since these are supposed to be written in essay form, I think it may have been useful to clearly state which literary techniques you were going to address at the beginning of your post. Don't mean to nag, only trying to be helpful. Overall, you provided great evidence for all of your points, so good work!
ReplyDeleteHi Helle,
ReplyDeleteGood close reading. I also did an article on the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare). I think this shows how much it was in the news and on everyone’s mind. You do a good job of using quotes as evidence to support your claims and having quotes spread out throughout your close reading makes it stronger. I would try to stay away from first person though in the close readings because it is supposed to be similar to a thesis driven essay and you aren’t supposed to use first person in a formal essay. Other than that though you do a good job explaining how the author contradicts themselves and that makes it unclear whether they oppose the Affordable Care Act or whether they are for it.
Hey Helle,
ReplyDeleteThis is an excellent close reading, you do a great job describing how the author fails to use language, details, and diction to successfully describe the issue of "Obamacare". Your Analysis of this was very well done, providing many evidence to support your claims throughout your body paragraphs. Like when you said "Finally, the diction employed by the author further proves how undeveloped their opinion on the issue of "Obamacare" is. Calling it a "disaster" in the beginning, to a great "help" in the final contradicts her main point. He/She does make it clear how they feel about the health care act, but with continuous contradictions, it makes it hard to believe that the author actually believes what they say they do. “That really does contradict what the author wants. Although like what Susheela and Eddie said, close readings are supposed to be like a formal essay not using first person voice but I'm sure this isn't a big problem to change. You just have to remember it for next time. Overall you did a great job of supporting your claims and thoughts of the author.