Saturday, October 26, 2013

Response to Course Material #2


After reading The American Dream by Edward Albee, we dove into the tragic story of Willy Loman inDeath of a Salesman by Arthur Miller. I’m typically not a fan of Arthur Miller and his works, though I have to say, Death of a Salesman changed my mind about him. Although extremely repetitive in basic, main ideas and written in unsophisticated language, the message that Miller makes clear is one that I find incredibly important. Like The American Dream, Miller’s Death of a Salesman stresses the theme of the American dream and its failure to fulfill everybody’s hopes.
            Willy believed for his whole life that he could make it big and achieve all of his aspirations, but when a single doubt entered his mind, he became depressed and very self-conscious. His whole life can be described as a constant uphill battle between his reality and his hopes; he calls Biff a lazy bum, only to call him anything but a bum the next moment in hopes that his son will become someone that he never was or will be. This conflict demonstrates many American peoples’ struggles of the 20th century: wanting to become the best of the best, to achieve the American dream, only to be shot down, since not everyone can become wealthy and have the perfect family lifestyle.  As Christopher Bigsby says (on the back of my copy of Death of a Salesman), “[Willy’s dream is] shared by all those who are aware of the gap between what they might have been and what they are” demonstrating the similarity in American peoples’ mindset. 
Seemingly, Miller is making the same point that other authors have done many times before and many times after him. However, Miller’s story is different. His play isn’t necessarily a story, and it isn’t as difficult to find the message of it as others are (like The American Dream, The Great Gatsby, etc). Rather, Death of a Salesman explores the mind of its main characters, and the causes and effects each of these characters present throughout the play. The characters are created based on the plot and meaning of the play, rather than the other way around. I found this to be incredibly appealing since, every time I have delved deep into analyzing a work of literature, it has been the latter. 
Miller’s work is considered by many not to be a tragedy. I definitely disagree with these people, and I generally believe, like Miller, that the feelings one feels while reading a piece of literature is what defines tragedy. While reading Death of a Salesman, the only word to describe how I was feeling was sad, and not just the typical frowny-face sad. I felt genuine pity and depression for each of the characters affected by Willy’s actions. However, learning about the different types of tragedy was very eye opening. It’s amazing how much a words meaning can change over the centuries. As defined by Aristotle, tragedy must include six specific parts that compile together to create a sense of pity or fear. This definition, to me, supports Miller's play as being defined as a tragedy, as it includes all six parts and instills pity immensely. However, definitions made in the Medieval era or Renaissance (Humanist) differ greatly. Medieval tragedy is defined as "the fall of a man from a high station to a low station" (according to the paper we got in class) which narrows the possibility of a work of literature to be a tragedy immensely. However, English Renaissance tragedy has the most rigorous set of rules of them all. With four specific events that must occur, of course it is impossible to define Death of a Salesman as a tragedy according to that definition. If a tragedy had to follow the rules of each of these definitions, the amount of tragic plays or novels would dramatically decrease, and a new genre of literature would have to be created: "sad". To me, definitions of words change over time as a rule of nature, and to follow such a strict pattern of rules is absurd.
Overall, I found Death of a Salesman and the lessons involved with it highly interesting. Each topic we discussed was new to me, and it made me challenge one of my favorite philosophers of all time (Aristotle).

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt p.1

2003 Question 3

Student A: This particular student starts off wonderfully. The writer immediately makes a claim that The Great Gatsby is a tragedy, at first throwing me off, since I never read the book that way. But, he/she proceeded to give evidence in all body paragraphs that proved Gatsby himself to be a tragic character. Using a good amount of quotes (not too little, not too many), he/she demonstrated knowledge of the meaning of the quotes by making a claim, warranting it, and then giving evidence. In his/her third paragraph, he/she wrote very eloquently about the death of Gatsby and the repercussions it had. He/she says, "as a tragic figure, [Gatsby's] character flaws cause the undoing of others" giving ample understanding of what it means to be a tragic character, and also what the tragic character typically does to other characters in a novel. He/she came full circle as well, discussing the roaring 20s and Gatsby's similarity to them in the beginning, and then discussing Gatsby's and 20s eventual demise. Using excellent diction, syntax, and imagery, this student paints a picture in my head about The Great Gatsby and it's deeper meaning that I never saw when I read it. Overall, this essay was very good. I would give it an 9/9.

Student B: Student B also starts off well, despite starting her introduction with a quote by someone else.  However, she (her handwriting looks really girly) has an otherwise very strong introduction that clearly states what she will be talking about in her following paragraphs. However, reading her first main argument, I couldn't get a sense of what point she was trying to make. She explained, very well, the story of King Leon and his three daughters, however, never fully described why King Leon was a tragic character until the beginning of her last paragraph. To me, this isn't a very good writing technique if someone is trying to explain something, because for the whole reading, I was just trying to understand what she was talking about. Although, it did come all together in the end, and for that, this essay was pretty good. Her syntax was what made the essay most easily comprehendible. By repeating words and phrases that emphasized King Leon's overly prideful and egotistical personality, she made it clear (eventually), why King Leon was a tragic character. I'd say this essay got about a 7/9.

Student C: This student does not get off to a good start. Her (I'm assuming yet again because of handwriting) introduction was barely formed, and there was no thesis statement that explained what she would write about in her following paragraphs. Her sentences are choppy, by ending them too early. "The novel takes place on the mental ward of a hospital.  A ward run by the strict & watchful eye of Nurse Ratched, or Big Nurse." Firstly, "on the mental ward" doesn't make sense. Secondly, she should have taken "A ward" out and added a comma after "hospital", making that sentence much easier to read. She proceeds to discuss the main character, McMurphy (apparently the tragic hero) and his tragic flaw (being unable to conform) however, gives no evidence as to why that is his tragic flaw, or what happened in the book to make Nurse Ratched kill him. This lead me to be incredibly confused, but even more confusing was how the student continued writing about the climax of the play, after she had said McMurphy died. Her essay is unorganized and predictable, and her language is unsophisticated. I honestly would give it a 3/9 or lower.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading #2


For my second close reading, I read an article regarding the adoption services of today’s America, specifically the faith-based ones. The author used language, syntax, and details to get their point across regarding the types of adoption services in the United States right now.

Starting off the article, the author writes clearly and concisely that he/she believes religious-affiliated adoption services should be allowed to practice their occupation how they see fit, without intervention from the state government. The language conveyed in this first sentence already tells me how the author feels about the situation, as well as how strongly they feel about it. He/she used a short, to-the-point sentence to get their opinion across and nothing else, showing they want to set up their argument right away. However, most of the author’s language seems to be compromising and defensive. He/she says, “In the case of Catholic agencies, that means not working with unmarried couples. But there are agencies that do work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples, including some that are faith based” showing the author’s want for appealing to everyone that has a part in the situation. He/she mentions that some of the agencies that work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples are faith based, demonstrating the author’s defense of religion, trying to show that faith based agencies aren’t as bad as everyone seems to think.

Next, the author’s use of syntax is limited, but worthy of covering. He/she uses short, concise statements throughout the article to force a thought or opinion into the readers’ heads. After stating the Department of Human Services were hopeful of an agreement between them and the committee of a faith based agency, the author said “They should work toward that” again making it clear what he/she believes, by use of a short, forceful sentence.

The author’s included details are what help he/she get their point across the best. Mentioning that some faith based agencies do in fact work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples may convince some of those people to reconsider disliking those types of agencies. Also, by telling the readers that “the state money isn’t providing profits for religious organizations; it’s spent on services for the children”, the author is allowing the reader to consider that maybe a religious affiliated organization for adoption may not be too bad. The author’s use of these details is to convince the non-religious side of the situation that faith based agencies aren’t actually as evil as people make them out to be.

To conclude, I found this article especially interesting to read. I didn’t know so many adoption agencies practiced faith, but I believe the author had many good points to make regarding the situation. This may have to do with his/her good use of language, syntax, and detail, that succeeded in making me think more about the subject.