Is it Protection?
Students used to only be punished
for what they did and said on school property, but with the invention of the
Internet, school administrators are looking to intensify the search for online
threats by students. However, students and administrators are debating whether
this will turn into an oppression of First Amendment rights. Using diction,
details, and ____, the author of Editorial
roundup: Internet changes school discipline makes it clear that they
believe schools have the right to punish students based off information gotten
off the Internet.
The author’s diction suggests that
free speech and constitutional rights for high school students can be void if
what the student says can be considered “reasonably likely to create
‘substantial disruption… with school activities’”. Using words such as
“rightly” to prove that the Supreme Courts 1969 ruling stating that administrators
had a right to sanction student expression if it caused disruption in the
school shows the author’s agreement with the ruling. At the end of the article,
the author states, “the courts are right to intervene when administrators
overreact to a student’s exercise of [freedom of speech]”. Using the word
“overreact” demonstrates the author’s viewpoint that a schools administrator
should investigate even the smallest “threat”. Also, by saying “a student’s
exercise of [freedom of speech]”, it suggests that students these days attempt
to see how far they can go with threats before someone intervenes. These
particular word choices only demonstrate the author’s standpoint that students
don’t have the right to free speech if it even remotely implies anything
illegal or threatening.
What shows author’s opinion most is
his detailing. He clearly avoids the topics such as what context his example of
threatening messages were sent in. Landon Wynar, the boy mentioned in the
article, apparently sent a threatening message that he claims to have been a
“joke”, but the school took a different viewpoint. Without the context of the
text, however, there is no way for the reader to determine what they think
about the situation. Another thing the author avoids is how far a schools
administration can go to finding out what students are posting online. Without
this information, there can be no way to decide if what administrations are
doing are in correlation with the First Amendment. The author’s point of not
including these details is clear – he doesn’t want the reader to think about
the other side of the argument, but rather wants them to agree with their
stance on the issue.
One major syntactical point I found
in the article was the author’s use of the word “But” at the beginning of a
large number of his sentences. By using the word “But” the author conveys that
the idea before the word is wrong and the next idea followed by “But” is
correct. In the first paragraph, the author makes note that before the Internet
was created, schools, rightly so, only punished students by what they said and
did on school property. “But” with the invention of the Internet, however, it
is now apparently able to disrupt school activities from off property according
to the author. This tactic, used throughout the article, stresses the
similarities in the author’s thoughts on the topic. He points out one side of
the argument, only to say “But” and prove that point virtually incorrect. His
cumulative use has an effect that demonstrates his point of view that school
administrations have a right to overreact toward any sort of threat seen on the
Internet or in text messaging conversations.
Just in this small article, diction,
detail, and syntax are heavily prevalent. The author’s use of words that express
his views without explicitly stating them, exclusion of relevant details, and
cumulative use of a transition word all point to how strongly opinionated the
author is on the matter of surveillance of high school students.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteI think your close reading blog is very important in realizing how to point out important pieces or literary terms in any article or essay out there. By starting off with diction, I think you made a great point with how the author uses sophisticated language to convey a certain idea to the passage. I liked also how you said diction so heavily relates to the tone and opinion of the author because it truly does, whether the author uses childish, sophisticated, threatening, or simple language a certain message comes across. Great comments on detailing because the amount of detail an author uses shows how passionate they are on the issue they are arguing. The last comments on syntax are important as well and I agree completely in the fact that you think syntax is the most important aspect of analyzing literature. My only improvement would be to talk a little bit more on imagery and language.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteI think you did a wonderful job on this close reading. You easily gave your arguments and you stuck to them thoroughly. You provided me with examples which are necessary and important when writing a close reading. For example, when you were describing the authors use of "But" then proceeding to back up your argument and I think you did it very nicely. Your close reading really guided me along and helped me point out the details that the author used like diction, syntax, and detailing. I also enjoyed how you expressed your opinion on how diction heavily related to the tone of this passage. I agree with Casey I think you should have maybe mentioned imagery and language, but overall I really liked your close reading. Good job!
Helle,
ReplyDeleteI think this is a good close reading, but there's room for improvement.
The first thing I noticed was that the link to the article you provided doesn't work. This could mean that the article was deleted, or that there was some error in your hyperlink use. In the case of the latter, you should pay much greater attention to your linking next time. Not being able to find your article takes away a lot of credibility from any arguments you make.
Next, in your second sentence there's a rather strange underscore, where there should be a word. Whether it's a joke or a formatting error, such an omission strikes a crucial blow against your close reading's validity. How can I judge whether you're supporting your argument when you've omitted the third literary technique you want to address? I would pay very close attention to such possible formatting errors next time.
Finally, I'd use the author's name more often next time. Inserting his/her name into the post serves as an informal citation, and weighs your direct quotes with more credence.
Despite these issues, this is a good post.