Sunday, March 16, 2014

Response to Course Material

Before starting Ceremony, we were finishing up Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. My class (maybe it was just me) had a hard time really getting the play. We bounced all the likely ideas, such as that maybe Stoppard was just mocking those literature analysts that look way too deeply into books and other works. Or he could have been pondering the idea of life and death and people's reaction toward the whole idea during their lifetime. Class discussions were entertaining, to say the least, but I found that I learned the most from reading various lectures and articles about the play. Specifically, the postmodern lecture was the most interesting analysis of any play we've read thus far. I learned a lot of new words (e.g. pastiche, diffĂ©rance, and epistemological) and I came to be more easily articulate about my understanding of the play. Personally, I thought the main undertone of the play was a commentary on life and death. Life, Stoppard infers, is confusing and filled with choices that most of us probably don't want to make or maybe don't even know how to make, like Ros and Guil. The only possible ending for life is death, Stoppard says, and "time is its only measure" (p 72).

Between discussing Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead and starting Ceremony we practiced different types of writing activities. We had intro/structure practice, where we had to write two of our own made open prompts and then write the structure of an essay for two peers own written open prompts. Writing the prompts was really fun for me. I tried to make it a balance between an academic and fun essay to write, appealing to both the intellectual and creative writer. Trying to find a good prompt to respond to was hard at first, but a lot of AP students are really creative with theirs too so I found a couple in no time.

To start off Ceremony, we had to go through the Tayo's World powerpoint, Silko's essays, and critical lenses prezi. The powerpoint was a good introduction to the novel, explaining the Pueblo culture so that while reading I didn't have to put my book down to look up what Silko was referencing. The critical lenses prezi was also informative, but I've already studied the different types of lenses, so it was basically a reminder for me. My favorite of the three to study was Silko's essays because she's just such a good writer. She's very enticing, almost manipulative at times, but always keeps me wanting to learn more. History books explain Native culture in the most basic terms, as simply and shortly as possible, but Silko writes with love for her people and shows rather than tells.

Reading Ceremony has been a pleasure as well. Finally, A BOOK. I've been waiting for this all year. Don't get me wrong, I've enjoyed each play we've read this year, but there's a certain depth I get from books that I can't get from plays. The recurring remarks about white people gets me a little defensive at times, but I remind myself that I'm a second generation American and Silko isn't really targeting my ancestors. Silko is amazing at pulling the reader in and realistically making me feel like I'm Tayo and I've just come back from the war. The characters, plot, and tense were all confusing at first, but after reading the beginning twice, things became less foggy. Whoever wrote the family tree on the board in class really helped me out too.

Finally, after discussing Ceremony, we began to discuss the various critical lenses and how each applied to the plays we read earlier this year. Regarding The American Dream, we touched on feminism, looking at quotes like "What a masculine Daddy!" and how that demonstrated Albee's possible scorn for women. Looking into Albee's past, we discussed the idea that maybe he regarded his adoptive mother as domineering and hateful toward his sexuality, whereas his adoptive father was more loving, but emasculated and dominated by his wife, reflecting Mommy and Daddy from the novel. We also discussed the possibility that the Young Man was a reflection of Albee himself. From a historic lens, one could make the connection between the time The American Dream was written and the materialistic manners of the new generation of America at the same time. For Death of a Salesman, we also looked at Arthur Miller's background to see the connection between the play and his life. I remember reading that Miller had an uncle like Willy; unable to recognize his own failure, but still convinced he's a success. A historic lens would point at the fact that at the time the play was written, America was essentially a flytrap for commercialism and big business, which is reflected in the play. From a colonial (or post colonian? Post modern colonial? I can't remember...) lens, Miller's references to the jungle can be seen as an insinuation that Americans are imperialist and domineering. We came up with two keys to success that Miller might have been outlining in his play. One can either lie, cheat, and steal to the top, or be honest and hardworking. Regarding the critical lenses as a whole, I'm a little confused as to why we looked at them so late in the year. I know Ms. Holmes was talking about it in class, but I think I missed the point. Why didn't we look at them while we were reading? Which do you guys think would have been better, looking at them in the beginning of the year or at the end like we are now?

Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt p. 2

2003: According to critic Northrop Frye, “Tragic heroes are so much the highest points in their human landscape that they seem the inevitable conductors of the power about them, great trees more likely to be struck by lightning than a clump of grass. Conductors may of course be instruments as well as victims of the divisive lightning.” Select a novel or play in which a tragic figure functions as an instrument of the suffering of others. Then write an essay in which you explain how the suffering brought upon others by that figure contributes to the tragic vision of the work as a whole.

In Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet's inconsistency and hesitation to take action takes a toll on the rest of royal family in Denmark and leads to each members inevitable death. 

From the beginning of the play, Hamlet is unable to make a consistent decision. His father's ghost tells him to kill his uncle, Claudius, but when given the perfect opportunity, Hamlet does not take it. He watches Claudius as he prays, armed with a dagger, able to kill his uncle at that very moment but decides he needs proof that his uncle killed his father. His hesitation to follow his fathers orders clearly disappointed him, leading to his most erratic behavior of the novel in the scene with his mother, Gertrude. Thinking that he heard a rat, Hamlet stabs through the closet curtains thinking it was Claudius, but actually killing Polonius. Instead of overly hesitating as he had earlier, he acts irrationally without any thought. Polonius's murder is the turning point of the novel where, here on out, death is the only option for the remaining characters.

After her fathers death, Ophelia, Hamlet's ex-girlfriend, goes mad after living a confused last few months being caught between instructions from her father and brother, Laertes, and Hamlet's demands. She kills herself, leaving Laertes an orphan with no family. He and Claudius plan to kill Hamlet during the duel between him and Laertes by poisoning the tip of Laertes sword and adding poisonous pearls to a glass of wine that Claudius will offer Hamlet. Eventually, Laertes and Hamlet kill each other with the poisoned sword, and Gertrude and Claudius drink the wine and die. If Hamlet had not hesitated in the beginning and killed his uncle when he had the chance, the events that followed would not have happened.

Hamlet's inability to follow his fathers wishes and kill his uncle leads to the deaths of the six major characters in the play making the play a textbook tragedy.

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead Summary and Analysis

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead
Author: Tom Stoppard
Setting: Late 1500s, in an unidentifiable location with “no visible character”, Hamlet’s palace, and a boat.

Plot:

  •  The play opens with R flipping coins and counting how many times they land on heads. The coins continuously fall on heads.
  • G is meanwhile philosophizing about the law of probability.
  • Neither R nor G remembers why they are traveling, except they know a messenger called for them earlier that day.
  • They encounter a group of actors called the Tragedians.
  • The leading actor, the Player, implies that their shows are sexual. He offers up Alfred to R & G for a price.
  • G and the Player begin to bet on a coin. It continually lands on heads which the Player guessed. When the Player changes his answer to tails, the coin continues to land on heads.
  • When the Players leave, right before the original characters of Hamlet appear, R tells G that the last coin flip ended up being tails.
  • R & G are now in Hamlet’s castle, being ordered by Claudius to spy on Hamlet.
  • R & G start to discuss how they will get information from Hamlet. They play a game of question and answer, meanwhile confusing their identities and purpose of action.
  • G suggests pretending being Hamlet so that R can fake-question him, revealing that they know why Hamlet is in a disturbed state of mind.
  •  Hamlet appears and mistakes R for G and G for R. Polonius appears to tell Hamlet the Tragedians have arrived.
  • When the cast of Hamlet leaves, R & G are left completely confused about Hamlet and whether he is insane or not.
  • The Player enters and he and R & G discuss the possible reasons for Hamlet’s strange behavior. R & G get off topic and discuss what happens after death.
  • R asks G if he thinks about being dead, lying in a box with a lid. G gets disturbed.
  • R continues to philosophize and says, "there's only one direction, and time is its only measure" hinting toward death and its inevitability
  • Shakespeare Act III scene i interrupts and Claudius, Gertrude, Polonius and Ophelia enter the play. R & G explain to them that Hamlet wants them all to attend the play.
  • Everyone leaves as Hamlet enters, not noticing R & G, and pondering about committing suicide. He and Ophelia leave the stage.
  • Alfred enters the stage, and R confuses him for the Queen. The Player and other tragedians enter, and rehearse the play performed in Hamlet.
  • R & G start to question the Player's concept of art, but the Player continues the rehearsal.
  • G then questions the Player's understanding of death and what it means. G thinks you can't act death, and the Player disagrees with him.
  • R & G are finally left alone and try leaving but confuse their directions again. They see Hamlet and notice he's carrying the dead body of Polonius but he immediately leaves the stage. He comes back later to accuse R & G of being Claudius's puppets.
  • Right as Claudius enters, Hamlet leaves. G tells R that they've been ordered to take Hamlet to England.
  • On the boat, R & G continue to question death. They attempt to practice their lines for when they meet the King of England and give the provided letter from Claudius. When they read the letter, they find out that Hamlet is to be executed upon arrival and they have no idea what to do. 
  • When R & G are asleep, Hamlet switches the letter for the one that he has written. They wake up and hear strange music coming from the barrels on the ship.
  • Suddenly, the Tragedians step out from the barrels and they watch as Hamlet escapes the boat. All the while, Pirates attack the boat though we never see them. 
  • R & G rehearse their lines for the King of England again, reading the letter that Hamlet put to replace the one he stole, seeing that they were now ordered to be executed upon arrival.
  • G and the Player get into an argument about death again, and G stabs the Player. He makes an outstandingly real death imitation, from which he brushes himself off from almost immediately. 
  • R doesn't care and thinks it was a marvelous performance but the G is still disturbed. 
  • R suddenly questions what they've been doing for the past while, and finally doesn't care about his inevitable destiny.
  • G still talks as R disappears, finally noticing, and accepting his destiny as well saying, "Now you see me, now you--" and dissapearing.
Main characters:

  • Rosencrantz: Stoppard only provided the reader with one literal character note for R: “[Rosencrantz] is nice enough to feel embarrassed at taking so much money off his friend. Let that be his character note.” Besides this, though, the reader can see that R is the more laid-back, care-free of the two friends. He doesn’t care why the coins continue to flip onto their heads. It takes him a while to understand what G wants him to do usually. He isn’t philosophical like G, but still has the ability to sensitively think, such as when he questions death (what it would be like to be dead or alive in a box with a lid). 
  • Guildenstern: The only character note for G was given like this: “Guil is well alive to the oddity of [coin flipping]. He is not worried about the money, but he is worried by the implications; aware but not going to panic about it—his character note.” The reader is able to tell that G is the more philosophical character of the two, however. He constantly questions the happenings around him because he’s anxious about the strange situation they find themselves in. He gets mad at R often when he doesn’t understand what G wants him to do, but usually softens later in the moment. 
  • The Player: The most mysterious character in the play. Seems to know more than R & G about the situation they find themselves in, and could tell them, but R & G never seem to ask the right questions. He’s an actor that travels with his fellow Tragedians, constantly “on-stage” throughout the play, unlike R & G who go back and forth from being “on-stage” to “off-stage”. Labeled as a pimp in the beginning when he offers R & G a “performance”—this being a sexual implication.

Narrative voice: Since Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is a play, there is no specific narrator.

Author’s style:

  • Point of view:  Since R & G are the main characters of the play, the play is mostly in their point of view. The reader follows them throughout the scenes and is directly involved with the emotions they experience.
  • Tone: Mocking, witty, playful, humorous, sarcastic.
  • Imagery: Often the only imagery Stoppard offers is blank and desolate, painting the environment as bland and showing that R & G are surrounded by nothingness.
  • Symbolism:
    • The coins: represent the control R & G don't hold over themselves. They land heads continually before they step on the Tragedians wagon, when it lands on tails.
    • The boat: represents life and the journey toward death; also the control that R & G don't have over their own lives, they don't steer the boat. 
Quotes:
1.      “Before we know the words for it, before we know that there are words, out we come, bloodied and squalling with the knowledge that for all the compasses in the world, there’s only one direction, and time is its only measure.” (p 72) 
When Rosencrantz unexpectedly philosophizes like this, we see the biggest question the book attempts to answer, which is what happens after death. Here, R states that death is the inevitable end to all human beings, and it happens with time. Unlike G, R accepts this more easily since he isn't as existentialist. 
2.      “Words, words. They’re all we have to go on.” (p 41)
When Guildenstern says this, it's actually Stoppard mocking the absurdity and meaningless of language. Throughout the entire play, R & G play on language with the question game and learning their lines for their encounters with Hamlet, the King, and others. Since R & G have so much trouble with communication, they don't have the ability to make sense of their lives.

Theme Statement: Tom Stoppard’s Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead questions the journey toward death and its impact on human existence. Rosencrantz and Guildentstern constantly question death and get anxious at not having control over when it will come. Rosencrantz once asked Guildenstern, "Do you ever think of yourself as actually dead, lying in a box with a lid on it?" to which Guildenstern has no other reply but "No." demonstrating the contrasting character notes between the two. Rosencrantz clearly has thought about death and what it would feel like, whereas Guildenstern refuses to talk about it. At the end of the play, both characters seem to accept their fate and disappear peacefully. The works title itself, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, sternly states that from the beginning, they were doomed for death and later, Rosencrantz himself hinted that time is the only thing keeping them from it. The boat and the fact that neither Rosencrantz or Guildenstern were steering it also demonstrates the fact that they (and actually all of us) have no control over when they will or how they will die.