Open Prompt 2004 Question 3
The author of Response 3A made their thesis clear in the introduction, stating right away what they thought was the central question, "Is this the best of all possible worlds?", to the novel Candide. In their body paragraphs, they wrote with detail why the central question was what it was by explaining the plot of the novel and the main character's role in making the central question to the novel clear. The author attempts to answer the question himself by analyzing, showing their thought process throughout their writing. Using strong and precise language as well as quotes from the novel, the author gives sufficient evidence to prove their thesis correct. The student overall did well in analyzing the novel and answering each of the points in the Open Prompt question.
Response 3B's author understands the question but does no know how to answer it. The central question she conjured from Mark Twain's The Adventures of Huckleberry and Finn was sufficient, however she did not use evidence from the novel that was relevant to it. Her question, "What does it mean to be free?" was never proven to be the dominant inquiry. She talked about Huck and Jim's enslaved state and then their freed state, but never discussed what it meant to either of them to be "free". Her unclear writing was marked by an understanding of what Huck and Jim's enslavement meant at the surface but a misunderstanding on what the two characters defined what freedom was to themselves. The author shows understanding of the prompt but she never fully dives into her argument, making her essay incomplete.
The author of Response 3C begins their essay with a clear-cut introduction, establishing the question, "Does anything ever stay the same?" that they thought was relevant to the novel Things Fall Apart. The question itself is very simple and could probably be used for a large number of other novels, demonstrating that any analysis would be surface level. Their body paragraphs had potential to develop into deeper discussions of the novel and it's central meaning, but they stayed vague throughout. Simple sentences that do not portray insightful understanding to even her own question make it hard for the reader to understand what exactly she is trying to say. "But as time gradually passed by, changes began to form" is only one of the sentences that did not provide sufficient insight into the topic of discussion. Overall, the author did not fully answer the question of the prompt.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteTo start off, I think the open prompts were supposed to be in three different entries for easy access. But, regardless, great comments on the AP Lit. Essays! I went through some of the same thoughts with my analyses because I had a hard time thinking of how to grade and what to comment on this variety of essays. However, it was super helpful having the grades and the comments by AP graders at the bottom to help with your own analysis and learn what you can do to further improve your own writing. Most of the previous essays that were shown as examples followed the theme of one being outstanding, one was pretty good, and one was just flat out terrible. As predicted, yours followed that theme.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteI think you were suppose to only have one prompt not three. Nonetheless, I think you did well. Although I would prefer to see some more examples on why the writer did not answer the question properly or why you did not agree with something the author had written. You used a quote in your last paragraph and that helped me understand your ideas better, I just wish you would have done that for the other two. Next time I think that you should incorporate the authors scores in the paragraphs because I am curious as to what they received instead of just reading that they "did not answer the prompt" How did author 3C remain vague over the essay? What were some examples of the authors simple sentences? Little questions like these could help bring your entire argument together.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteOverall, I like this post. You analyze the three responses well, and demonstrate a clear understanding of what the elements of a good prompt-response are.
Throughout your analysis, your gender assignments to the anonymous authors are un-neutral and inconsistent. You switch between "they," "himself," and "she" frequently. Next time, I would keep better track of your use of gender related words.
You also switch between present and past tense, which, while being less important than gender related assumptions, is something to look out for in an any piece of academic writing. When referring to an author writing something, it's safe to stay in the past tense. You should only use present tense when referring to the fictional events of a story.
The fact that my only criticisms are nit-picky things speaks to the strength of this post.