Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt p.1

2005 Question 1

Student #1: This student starts off with a clear and concise paragraph of the two poems to which he (I assume because of handwriting) will be analyzing. His first body paragraph compares the two poems stylistically, using ample evidence in the form of quotations. He comments on the rhyme scheme of the poems and the similarities and differences between them. His second body paragraph talks of the main differences between the poems, specifically the tone, which he describes in detail. His diction throughout the essay is refined, using words such as "dichotomous" and "theistic" to characterize the poems. Though there is no conclusion paragraph, this student deserves at 8 or higher for his ample analytic and observational skills.

Student #2: This student begins his introductory paragraph very well, by stating the aspects of the two poems for which he will be analyzing (syntax and diction). In his first body paragraph, he uses the author of the poem's diction to create meaning for the tone, showing that he can draw out different tools of writing from only one to start with. The student mainly focuses on imagery throughout their essay, comparing the colors the author uses in his poem to justify deeper meanings in the two poems. Though the essay is quite mechanical, the student shows understanding of the two poems and is able to communicate their findings in a well thought out manner. I feel this student deserves a 6.

Student #3: This student starts her essay off quite disorganized. The introductory paragraph isn't quite introductory, rather it dives into analyzing the tone of both poems right away. The transition into the body paragraph is shaky, since the subject goes from tone to what is literally being told in the poem. Her two body paragraphs to describe the role of God in both poems are both short, unclear, and don't have much evidence to support her claims. It seems she was rushed, for in her conclusion paragraph, she jumps from speaking about the differences of the role of God in the poems, to the rhyme scheme, and then back to the tone. Overall, the student's lack of focus confuses the reader and she deserves a 4.

3 comments:

  1. Good stuff, Helle. You clearly put a significant amount of thought into the construction of these critiques. As always, it seems as though the first essay was the strongest. I liked how you provided specific examples of what the student did right, like commenting on the rhyme scheme identifying the student's careful use of diction. The second essay, as you noted with ample support, was not as effective in it's response to the prompt. While it covered all the bases, it lacked a sense of fluidity (you said it was too mechanical) and placed too much focus on one literary technique, imagery, that prevented it from being a well-rounded piece of analysis. Do you think that if the student's lack of adequate syntactical analysis kept him from earning a higher score?I certainly do. Lastly, you found the third essay to be the weakest, and I would have to heartily agree there as well. The student's lack of focus is definitely the source of the problem here, and he/she writes like she is scrambling to include all of here ideas with a reckless disregard for organization. For me, the fact that the student tried to include new topics for analysis into her conclusion paragraph was really the nail in the coffin. Honestly, I think the 4 you gave him/her was a little generous. That aside, this is a quality post. Way to go!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Helle,
    I think you accidentally did a closed prompt instead of an open prompt. I did this same closed prompt by accident for one of my earlier posts. The difference between a closed prompt and open prompt is that when writing an essay for a closed prompt the piece(s) of literature are already selected for you. In an open prompt the student can choose what to write his or her essay about. Another technical thing is that when we analyze the poems our response to them needs to be between 150-200 words. You might want to write in the beginning what the question was too that those students had to answer. Others than these technical things (mainly doing an open prompt), your analysis is good.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Helle,
    I think Susheela's right about you doing a close prompt instead of an open prompt. I just remember that all 3rd question prompts of any year is the open prompts. Haha, don't worry because you're not the only that had make that mistake before. Anyways, I think you did great job of doing an analysis on the essays, given that you didn't know it wasn't a open prompt. I also liked that you added your own opinion on what the essays and what score they deserved. The only thing i would like to see is what the Ap Scorers had said about these essays and what your thoughts on that? Like did you agree or disagree? Overall you did well.

    ReplyDelete