Sunday, February 16, 2014

Response to Course Material

Since our last response to course material, we've been reading Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. Though my grasp on the plays meaning is still weak, it has grown since first reading it aloud in class. While reading Rosencrantz's part, I initially only caught the humor of the play; the witty but absurd banter between R & G was incredibly hilarious. Reading it as one of the main characters was especially helpful and really fun.

Watching the movie was a great experience as well. I find it really awesome that Stoppard himself directed it, because it almost gives us no room to assume anything differently and we can see exactly into his imagination. Obviously the film helped me answer many simple plot questions, such as order of events, and symbolic meanings to do with direction. The fact that the ending of the movie differed from that of the book was interesting. In the film, R & G are hanged and then the doors to the Player's wagon are closed and the actors continue their travels in the forest seen at the beginning of the movie. The only thing I can infer from this is that Stoppard is telling us that R & G are actors as well, and the entire story took place on the stage of the wagon. Why Stoppard added this change is unknown to me--maybe after twenty-three years he realized he needed to make the ending of his play more clear for its readers?

The Stoppard lecture annotations were also helpful in realizing certain aspects of the play, such as the theatre of the absurd. He outlined the requirements a play needed to be absurd, like protagonists "incapable of independent action" and just waiting for someone to give them direction. This along with verbal humor and protagonist game-play fit perfectly with R & G. Eventually, however, the lecturer concludes that Stoppard's play isn't necessarily theatre of the absurd, rather it's more of a mockery of Shakespeare's own Hamlet, kind of confusing me since he built a ton of evidence to the former and and none for the latter. The lecture had no impact on me regarding meaning or theme, though, which didn't help me make any more sense of the play in that aspect.

To this moment, all I can say about Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is what I've read and listened to other people say. Our discussions on Wednesday and Thursday confused me--are we on a boat? Who is in control of the boat? Do fate and free will exist? Are the pirates real? Are R & G friends because of circumstance or because they actually have a close relationship? What is Stoppard's view on death? I can literally answer zero of these questions with the hope of making any intellectual comment. Hopefully I'll become less ignorant and more comfortable with this work in the near future.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt p.2

2005 Q1

Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman portrays the tension between outward conformity and inward questioning in the character of Willy Loman. For his whole life, Willy is unable to realize his inclination toward labor work because of societal pressure to get careers in law, business, sales, etc. Miller’s use of this tension is actually a social commentary on the appeal and assured disappointment of the so-called “American dream” and it’s effects on Willy’s life.

Throughout the novel, Willy often expresses himself in contradictory ways. Before he left for work the morning of the beginning of the play, he criticizes his son Biff for working as a manual laborer on farms out West. Not many moments later he declares Biff is anything but lazy. Later in his encounter with his boss, Howard, Willy cries out that he averaged $180 dollars a week in 1928. Howard uncomfortably but firmly denies this, but Willy clings onto the belief that he is good at his job, when his poor salesmanship clearly doesn’t account for that. Willy’s constant lying and contradictory behavior only emphasize his identity crisis. He wants to be a professional, good working salesman but he acts like a low class manual worker. Miller’s statement with this is that the American dream does not pan out for those who do not work hard and innovate—and that wealth and reputation are not what lead to success.

Another motif Miller uses in Death of a Salesman is nature versus city—or, superficiality and commercialization. The tall apartment buildings that surround Willy’s once air-space clear yard block the sunlight and render him unable to grow his plants. The buildings represent the city, where Willy performs his job that he is clearly unfit for and pretends to be something he isn’t. The fact that his appliances, like his fridge and his car, continue to brake and cost more to fix than what he makes as a meager salesman ironically displays the simple truth: Willy can’t actually afford anything he has doing a job supposedly assuring good old American success.
            Miller’s play is a commentary on the faulty expectations of the American dream, and it’s effect on ones family, work, and personal life.


Saturday, February 1, 2014

Hamlet Summary and Analysis

Hamlet

Author: William Shakespeare. Wrote Hamlet between 1600 and 1602.

Setting: In the late medieval period, during the Elizabethan Era. Takes place in the castle and it's surrounding areas, in Elsinor, Denmark.

Plot: 

  • Act 1:

    • Horatio and guards see the ghost of Old Hamlet, the former king of Denmark
    • Claudius grants Laertes leave to France, and he and Gertrude deny Hamlet request to go back to Wittenburg
    • Hamlet is clearly grieving over how short a time it was between his fathers death and the marriage of his mother to his father's brother, and Claudius and Gertrude basically tell him to get over it
    • Laertes and Polonius warn Ophelia to stay away from Hamlet.
    • Hamlet is told about his father's ghost from Horatio, and they along with Marcellus visit the ghost
    • The ghost extracts Hamlet from the trio and explains to him that his brother, Claudius, killed him and he requests Hamlet to take vengeance on him
  • Act 2: 
    • Polonius sends someone to spy on Laertes in France
    • Hamlet visits Ophelia in a weird craze
    • Polonius incorrectly assumes that Hamlet's madness can be explained by his separation from Ophelia ever since she broke it off with him
    • Gertrude and Claudius tell Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to spy on Hamlet
    • Polonius tells Ophelia that Hamlet's madly in love with her
    • Hamlet finds out that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are prying him for information for the King and Queen.
    • Hamlet makes a plan to see if his uncle is actually guilty by staging a play that reenacts the death of Old Hamlet
  • Act 3:
    • Rosencrantz and Guildenstern can't find the reason for Hamlet's madness
    • Claudius and Polonius spy on Hamlet and Ophelia's conversation
    • Hamlet says he never loved Ophelia, gets crazy, and leaves her on the ground crying
    • Claudius sees that there's more to Hamlet's madness than just his weird relationship situation with Ophelia and orders him to be sent to England
    • The play is put on, Claudius shows his guilt
    • Hamlet is asked to see Gertrude
    • Hamlet happens to see Claudius praying and is about to finish his business, but decides to wait
    • Polonius spies on Hamlet and Gertrude's conversation
    • Hamlet scares Gertrude who screams for help, causing Hamlet to take notice of someone behind the curtain. Hamlet unknowingly kills Polonius, thinking it was Claudius
    • Hamlet yells at his mother and explains her awful actions
    • The Ghost appears to remind Hamlet of his mission, but Gertrude cannot see him so she thinks Hamlet's actually crazy
  • Act 4:
    • Gertrude informs Claudius of Polonius's death
    • Ros and Guil immediately take Hamlet to England
    • Hamlet won't reveal where Polonius's body is, sees Fortinbras's army as he's being sent away
  • Act 5:
    • Two clowns dig up Yorick's grave to make room for the dead Ophelia
    • Hamlet and Laertes fight over her grave briefly
    • Hamlet finds Yorick's skull and is reminded of the inevitability of death
    • Hamlet finally relinquishes control and accepts death
    • He duels with Laertes, who poisoned the tip of his sword to kill Hamlet as he planned with Claudius.
    • Claudius puts poisonous pearls in wine that he attempts to offer Hamlet, who doesn't take any
    • Gertrude takes the wine from Claudius and drinks it, dying, meanwhile Hamlet and Laertes are both cut by the poisonous tip of the sword
    • Hamlet discovers his mother is dying and the reason why, and he kills Claudius
    • Fortinbras walks in after the bloodbath, entering as new King of Denmark

Main Characters:

  • Hamlet: Central character of the play. Son of Old Hamlet, whose Ghost orders him to avenge his death upon his uncle. Hamlet's internal struggle between his fathers request and his religious beliefs is the cause of his ultimate demise. Has fling with Ophelia, and most likely impregnated her. Suicidal throughout the play.
  • Claudius: New King of Denmark at the beginning of the play. Married Gertrude, Hamlet's mother, after killing Old Hamlet with poison to the ear. Wicked man who doesn't regret his actions. Eventually dies at the hands of Hamlet after attempting to plot his death with Laertes.
  • Gertrude: Hamlet's mother, who incestuously marries her late husband's brother, deeply upsetting Hamlet. Eventually realizes her mistake and arguably dies to protect Hamlet.
  • Polonius: Father of Laertes and Ophelia. Has immense political power. Killed by Hamlet while spying on him and Gertrude.
  • Laertes: Polonius's son, who lives in France for most of the play but comes back to take vengeance on Hamlet, who killed Polonius. Duels with Hamlet and dies by the tip of his own poisoned sword.
  • Ophelia: Polonius's daughter, who has a fling with Hamlet. She most likely is pregnant, and arguably kills herself because of her shame.
  • Horatio: Hamlet's main man. The most trustworthy character in the play. 

Narrative voice: There is no narrative voice.

Authors style:
  • POV: Shakespeare wrote the play as though it was during the Elizabethan Era, though it took place in Denmark and during the monarchy period of the 1200s.
  • Tone: Shakespeare's overall tone of the play is disapproving of the actions of the family and those involved in the main conflict. His tone accounts for the subsequent deaths of the everyone at the end of the play. Throughout the play, a dark and depressed tone is exemplified in the constant suicidal thoughts by Hamlet, the death of Ophelia, and the bad actions every main character makes.
  • Imagery: Shakespeare uses nature to evoke certain emotions from the reader. Ophelia kills herself by drowning in a pond surrounded by flowers, reminding us of their symbolism. Yorick's skull is randomly dug up from the earth, showing us the inevitability of death and the uncertainness of what may happen afterwards. Old Hamlet was poisoned during his nap in the forest, again reminding the reader of death and the importance of nature.
  • Symbols:
    • the Ghost - the spiritual consequences of death; the devil; bad choices.
    • Yorick's skill - the physical consequences of death; the inevitability of death
    • Flowers
      • Rue - regret
      • Rosemary - remembrance 
      • Violets - innocence
Quotes:

  • "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark." (Act 1, Scene 4)
    • Marcellus may not have realized it, but he was actually foreshadowing the events that would follow his remark. This quote establishes the poison and sickness that has inhibited the royal family of Denmark, and the rest of the play portrays the inevitable demise of them.
  • "To be, or not to be: that is the question" (Act 3, Scene 1)
    • Hamlet's most quoted soliloquy is important for a reason--it highlights the biggest conflict in the play.  Hamlet's struggle between completing his fathers ghost's wish to kill his uncle and his religious beliefs. This is Hamlet's biggest mental breakdown as well; he continues to tell us that he wants to die but doesn't know what will happen to him after death.
Theme statement: Shakespeare's Hamlet warns us of the mental perils that await should we struggle with our identities and never relinquish control of our fate. Throughout the play, Hamlet battles between his father's request and providence. His eventual decision to let fate work it's magic leads to his death. However sad his death may be, it is nonetheless fortunate for Elsinor. Each death in the play marked the poisonous roots leaving the kingdom. Shakespeare uses symbols to demonstrate his point, such as Yorick's skull, which reminds the reader of the inevitability of death and the uncertainty of afterlife.