Friday, December 27, 2013

Response to Course Material #4


            For most of the time after our last response to course material, we’ve been covering Shakespeare’s Hamlet. While this is my favorite Shakespeare play that I’ve read so far, it took me a long time to actually understand the play and it’s confusing diction, syntax, language, imagery, and details.
         While we were just reading the play out loud, my mind was occupied on how to read Laertes, the players’, and other minor characters lines. Although the bulk of the play was blank verse, the various sonnets, soliloquys, and other poetic styles of writing surprised me and were impossible to understand the first time read. When we began to watch the movies, I started to realize more about the plot, characters, and meaning of the play.
         Firstly, before I can make a concrete opinion of any of the five films we watched, I should watch the movies in full. However, based on the scenes that we did watch, I think I can form an idea of how I would feel were I to watch the whole film.
         The Branagh version was my second least favorite of the five films. Overall, I thought it was over-dramatic, it made me uncomfortable, but the set up of the castle and costumes were excellent. Ophelia was weird and too cooky, which was disappointing since I thought Kate Winslet would play a great Shakespearian character. The flashbacks were unnecessary and confusing, but most of all the ending was my least/favorite part of the movie. I thought the part where the chandelier rammed into Claudius’ back was over-dramatic, and Fortinbras’ army was never actually attacking Elsinor, but the crumbling statue of Hamlet was a good touch. It symbolized the fall of his family and Polonius’s, and the cleansing of Elsinor. A good critic, John Simon, said Branagh’s direction used  “explicitness where Shakespeare[…] settled for subtlety or mere suggestion” which I thought explained the movie as a whole very well. In my mind, Hamlet was a quick and sharp-tongued man who knew how to make what he was saying more complicated than it needed to be for the purpose of mocking his peers, rather than a hot-heated, heavy-breathing mad man.
         The second film, with David Tennant playing Hamlet was my least favorite. I didn’t like the modern clothing added with Old English language. I know Shakespeare intended his play to be recognized in any time period, but I think if you dress modernly, you should speak modernly. Personally, I think keeping it the way it was portrayed in Shakespeare’s time allows the watcher to gain a better understanding of the mannerisms, dress, and language of the time. Tennant’s portrayal was dramatic as well. Why was he never wearing shoes? Why did he keep running frantically back and forth from Ophelia to the door in the break up scene (again, I think with no shoes on)? At the end of the play, why did Claudius shrug before his death? All of these questions kept me from enjoying the interpretation of the play. Only one thing was interesting and appealing to me: the fact that the same person portrayed Claudius and old Hamlet. I think this brought up a lot of different meanings to young Hamlet’s father situation such as whether his uncle was more of a dad to him than his own father.
         Jacobi’s portrayal of Hamlet in the 1980 film was my favorite at first, right up until the awkward rape-like scene between him and his mother. Why did he have to start humping her? This acting made me so uncomfortable I couldn’t concentrate and the movie was pretty much ruined for me. However, the old-fashioned costumes and dark lighting were good touches and made the play seem more “realistic” to me. Also, I know that the Ophelia in this film in particular was supposed to be awful, but I never really saw how bad she was. Maybe after watching the film fully I’ll see differently, though. Laertes, however, was a different story. He was so bad in this film that, like Ms. Holmes said, I can’t believe his co-actors and actresses weren’t laughing the whole time at him.
         Ethan Hawke’s Hamlet was my least favorite in regards to setting and costume, but my favorite in regards to interpretation. The death scene where Laertes, Claudius, and Hamlet all die by gunpoint defeats the purpose of a personal kill with a blade. But Ophelia, played by Julia Stiles (one of my favorite 90s/early 2000s actresses), is the best of all the films. The scene between her and Hamlet was the only one where Hamlet wasn’t breathing in her face and attacking her with his crazed eyes, and the only one where Ophelia acted as though she didn’t care to break up with Hamlet. The Ghost scene was also enjoyable since Hamlet didn’t fall to the ground at the sight of his father, like the majority of the other films. Laertes, played by Liev Schreiber, another one of my favorite actors, was levelheaded for the most part and played the older brother to Ophelia really well. Gertrude’s impression that she knew the drink made by Claudius was poisoned but drank it anyways was also something to appreciate about the movie, since I like the idea of Gertrude coming to her senses and “joining” Hamlet’s side. An interesting aspect of the film is that Hamlet was a film student, something I don’t understand. Is it to show that he isn’t the most academic student and is more artsy? What does this mean for the play?
         Lastly, the Olivier version was my second favorite of the films. I loved how it was black and white, the clothing was old fashioned, and the setting along with the acting, wasn’t over-dramatic. Like Ethan Hawke’s version, Gertrude knew the drink Claudius made was poisoned. Overall, the film seemed to stay close with the play and didn’t over-interpret everything.
         After watching the movies, we were given an essay, Tragic Balance in Hamlet by Philip Edwards. The first time reading this through, I had no idea what Edwards was trying to say. I couldn’t understand from whose point of view he was writing or what his point was, but after giving it a couple more reads, I understand bits and pieces. He brings up a quote that Knight says about Hamlet “[losing] in the end because he gives in to the ghost and ‘descends to the level of Laertes’” which I disagree with. Before the fight between Laertes and Hamlet, Hamlet admits to Horatio that he accepts death and God’s power to decide his fate, whereas Laertes, until he was cut, attempted to control another person’s life. One of the points I agree with is that the Ghost is not an innocent spirit but rather a “false spirit from hell” because an innocent spirit wouldn’t come back to earth to ask his son to avenge his death.
         My interpretation of Hamlet still hasn’t been solidified; I don’t think it ever will be. However, what I do think now is that Hamlet was never really mad-he loved Ophelia and her death shocked him and sent him into a crazed jump into her grave. The other scenes were an act to confuse and get attention from his peers. 

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt p.1

2004 Question 2

Student A demonstrates an ability to read between the lines of Henry James' "The Pupil" as shown through his understanding of the irony and mockery displayed in the piece. He separately discusses the three characters, Mrs. Moreen, Morgan Moreen, and Pemberton, making for a good, organized essay. The student avoids mere plot summary by giving examples from the text and then explaining them to fit his thesis. Though this student's essay was not error free (there were quite a few grammatical and spelling errors), his understanding of the short story and ability to analyze it was clear. He was awarded with an 8; I would award him with a 9.

Student B does not start her essay very well. Her thesis, "By closely examing "The Pupil" one can see that Henry James creates contrasting characters that work together to create a story" literally doesn't say anything. What will she be discussing in her later paragraphs? What does it mean they "work together to create a story"? In her first paragraph, she compares Mrs. Moreen to Pemberton. She makes the claim that "one gets a sense of [carelessness] through Pemberton's opening thoughts regarding money" but never shares what his thought was, leaving me unable to relate to the sense of carelessness. Although this doesn't bode well for her score, in general, she shows an understanding of James' message of the social structure in the time period. Her language goes in circles at times, but her references to the text allow us to realize her basic analytic ability. She was given a 6, however I would give her a 5.

Student C shows a very low level of analytical skill. Rather than write about tone, diction, or other literary tools used by writers, the student concentrates more on how she felt about the piece. "My favorite part of this reading was the author's characterization" is simply not what one says in an analytical essay. However, she does continue on to comment on the characters character and how it's shown through their actions. She makes a lame comment on the "vibrant and believable" imagery of the piece as well, showing a basic understanding of DIDLS and the meaning they bring to a work of literature. Despite this, the bulk of the essay amplified the student's weak ability to read, analyze, and comment on "The Pupil".

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading #4


Democrats and Republicans have been angrily disputing the new Affordable Care Act for months now. Using diction, language, and details, Scott Brown in his article, Stunning hypocrisy from Democrats in wake of ObamaCare’s broken promises leaves no room for debate as to whose side he’s on amidst this conflict.
           
The first words one see this article are “hypocrisy” and “double standards”. Given the name of the article, these words are clearly placed in the very beginning to paint a picture in the readers mind right away about Obamacare and its Democratic supporters. Brown leads off with “as the new law implodes before our eyes” before reciting the details of Obamacare’s shaky rollout. By choosing to say the law “imploded”, Brown is attempting to make us picture an unstable disaster that collapsed upon itself because of its numerous flaws. Brown makes it really clear what he thinks when he blatantly calls the law a “catastrophe” – an intense word choice that we often identify with events such as hurricane Katrina. The diction employed by Scott Brown is helpful in identifying his bias toward the Affordable Care Act. 

Another helpful tool is Brown’s language. After discussing the unfortunate cases of some Americans’ issues with ObamaCare, he says some people “all of a sudden find themselves out of luck.” This language seems to make the misfortune of millions of Americans extremely casual. By making it seem so casual, Brown is actually mocking the Democrats and their apparent apathy toward those Americans who have lost their health plan. When discussing Democrat’s refusal to compromise with Republicans, Brown says they’re “stubbornly digging in their heels”, creating a mocking tone. The language of this sentence makes us image little, spoiled bratty kids who won’t listen to their parents until they get what they want. Brown’s language throughout the article is mocking, intended to make the reader disgusted by Democrats and their childish actions.

The third tool Brown uses to emphasize his point that ObamaCare is a disaster is detail. At the beginning of the article, he says Americans were “repeatedly assured by President Obama” that they could keep their health plan if they wanted to. With the detail that the President “repeatedly” said this, when Brown later mentions that millions of Americans have actually lost their plans, the reader is meant to get mad, as though they’ve been let down “repeatedly”. He continues to say “approximately 5 million people [are] expected to lose their current plan and millions more [are] to follow.” With the detail that “millions more [are] to follow” the reader is being emotionally appealed to. They’re made to fear, “am I next?” in turn making the reader unsure of their feelings about ObamaCare. The details used by Brown are clearly an attempt at changing the reader’s initial thoughts about the law.

Using diction, language, and details, Brown successfully makes it difficult to think positively about the new Affordable Care Act passed by the Obama Administration. However, with their use, it is also difficult not to see his clear bias and hatred toward ObamaCare and it’s supporters.

http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2013/12/03/stunning-hypocrisy-from-democrats-in-wake-obamacare-broken-promises/?intcmp=trending

*On a side note, could someone shed some light as to where to put any punctuation following a quote? The way I did it in this article seems a little off to me.