2005 Q1
Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman portrays the tension
between outward conformity and inward questioning in the character of Willy
Loman. For his whole life, Willy is unable to realize his inclination toward labor
work because of societal pressure to get careers in law, business, sales, etc.
Miller’s use of this tension is actually a social commentary on the appeal and
assured disappointment of the so-called “American dream” and it’s effects on
Willy’s life.
Throughout the novel, Willy often expresses himself in
contradictory ways. Before he left for work the morning of the beginning of the
play, he criticizes his son Biff for working as a manual laborer on farms out
West. Not many moments later he declares Biff is anything but lazy. Later in
his encounter with his boss, Howard, Willy cries out that he averaged $180
dollars a week in 1928. Howard uncomfortably but firmly denies this, but Willy
clings onto the belief that he is good at his job, when his poor salesmanship
clearly doesn’t account for that. Willy’s constant lying and contradictory
behavior only emphasize his identity crisis. He wants to be a professional,
good working salesman but he acts like a low class manual worker. Miller’s
statement with this is that the American dream does not pan out for those who
do not work hard and innovate—and that wealth and reputation are not what lead
to success.
Another motif Miller uses in Death of a Salesman is nature versus city—or, superficiality and
commercialization. The tall apartment buildings that surround Willy’s once
air-space clear yard block the sunlight and render him unable to grow his
plants. The buildings represent the city, where Willy performs his job that he
is clearly unfit for and pretends to be something he isn’t. The fact that his appliances,
like his fridge and his car, continue to brake and cost more to fix than what
he makes as a meager salesman ironically displays the simple truth: Willy can’t
actually afford anything he has doing a job supposedly assuring good old
American success.
Miller’s play is a commentary on the faulty expectations
of the American dream, and it’s effect on ones family, work, and personal life.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteThis is a pretty well-written open prompt essay.
I like how you remembered to address the meaning of this piece (“social commentary on the appeal and assured disappointment of the so-called ‘American dream’ “) It would be better, however, if you used some more literary terms when making claims or providing examples. Also, if you provided more examples regarding Willy’s state of mind in his battle between outside conformity and inside opinions, it would be more sufficient (having 3 body paragraph is usually best).
Also, you should try to be more concrete with your wording. For example, in your introductory paragraph, you could say “white collar workers” as opposed to “law, business, sales, etc.”
Finally, your conclusion should be a longer.
Overall, this open prompt essay is probably a 5/9 (random guess).
Hello Helle
ReplyDeleteAt first glance, I am a bit concerned with the length of this essay. However, time is short, and I am not really one to criticize considering my own issues with time restraints.
I am not completely sure where your thesis statement is going, and I am not convinced that it addresses the question given. Perhaps emphasizing how Willy's internal and external pressures create the issues that he faces can help you with your introduction.
You bring good evidence to your body paragraphs. I would like to see stronger topic sentences and more reasoning behind how these elements tie back to your assertion in the beginning of the essay. The second body paragraph is also a concern, as you are referring to motifs that Miller uses instead of making a statement that addresses the question and gets supported by evidence and reasoning.
Your final paragraph is a bit lacking, which is understandable given the time restraints. However, I would still like to see more than one sentence.
Hi Helle,
ReplyDeleteGood job! I like how you consciously went for tackling the theme statement in this essay. I know that's something I struggle with.
One quick thought I had was that I'd stay away from using "etc." in these essays. I'd certainly concede the point if Ms. Holmes disagrees with me, but my own impression is that for a more formal essay like this, I would write with more concrete words, instead of leaving ideas up in the air with "etc."
In any case, I definitely see a great essay waiting to be fleshed out from your ideas here. Right now it's just that your ideas like to jump around a tiny bit, so I think you could tie your individual topic sentences to your thesis and your evidence to your topic sentences a little more. Especially going into your nature vs. city paragraph, I had no idea what direction you were going to take that in.
Hope this helps!