Watching the movie was a great experience as well. I find it really awesome that Stoppard himself directed it, because it almost gives us no room to assume anything differently and we can see exactly into his imagination. Obviously the film helped me answer many simple plot questions, such as order of events, and symbolic meanings to do with direction. The fact that the ending of the movie differed from that of the book was interesting. In the film, R & G are hanged and then the doors to the Player's wagon are closed and the actors continue their travels in the forest seen at the beginning of the movie. The only thing I can infer from this is that Stoppard is telling us that R & G are actors as well, and the entire story took place on the stage of the wagon. Why Stoppard added this change is unknown to me--maybe after twenty-three years he realized he needed to make the ending of his play more clear for its readers?
The Stoppard lecture annotations were also helpful in realizing certain aspects of the play, such as the theatre of the absurd. He outlined the requirements a play needed to be absurd, like protagonists "incapable of independent action" and just waiting for someone to give them direction. This along with verbal humor and protagonist game-play fit perfectly with R & G. Eventually, however, the lecturer concludes that Stoppard's play isn't necessarily theatre of the absurd, rather it's more of a mockery of Shakespeare's own Hamlet, kind of confusing me since he built a ton of evidence to the former and and none for the latter. The lecture had no impact on me regarding meaning or theme, though, which didn't help me make any more sense of the play in that aspect.
To this moment, all I can say about Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is what I've read and listened to other people say. Our discussions on Wednesday and Thursday confused me--are we on a boat? Who is in control of the boat? Do fate and free will exist? Are the pirates real? Are R & G friends because of circumstance or because they actually have a close relationship? What is Stoppard's view on death? I can literally answer zero of these questions with the hope of making any intellectual comment. Hopefully I'll become less ignorant and more comfortable with this work in the near future.
Helle,
ReplyDeleteThis was a thorough and well-written response to course materials.
I agree that “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern” was a confusing play. Even after finding the theme statement, I believe we missed some key aspects of the absurd play (like Providence). I disagree that watching the Stoppard directed “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern” movie leaves no room to make assumption, because, like Ms. Holmes said, the author is not always right. The reader can make a different interpretation from the author and still be just as correct. There was a quote by Stoppard himself saying that the play is intended to have several interpretations. The movie however did help us gain more insight.
Now that you have been in more class discussions, however, do you think you have answered some of the questions in this Response to course materials?
Hello Helle,
ReplyDeleteGlad to hear that your understanding of the play is expanding. I admit, when I started reading the play by myself, I thought I understood a bit of it. Of course, I didn't, and Ms. Holmes, the film, and the lecture notes have been invaluable in clarifying the play to me. I also really enjoyed the class discussions for this piece; we seemed free to probe any idea out there, no matter how outrageous. Of course, not too many questions were answered on our part. How were your class discussions? Did you enjoy them?
Hi Helle,
ReplyDeleteYou're definitely not ignorant! I feel like our job as AP Lit students is to soak in tons of ideas and knowledge in class (with the text, movie, lecture, and discussion for R&G). That's about when this blog post was due. Then we had to work individually and together to tie all of that information together. Not being able to tie information together just yet doesn't make you ignorant. It makes you just like the rest of us :)
Overall, this was a very good post! You've reflected personally on Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. The only thing is that I wonder if you could add some outside connections too...after all, literature exists in the real world, and so should our thoughts on literature!