Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompt p. 2

2004. Critic Roland Barthes has said, "Literature is the question minus the answer." Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.

In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, one central question to he play that kept coming to mind was: Will hamlet ever relinquish control? The answer up until the last act of the play certainly seems to be no, but just as Hamlet becomes as crazy controlling as can be, his mood shifts. Through three scenes, Hamlet’s decision continues...

In one of the first scenes of the play, Hamlet encounters the ghost of his father and is told that he was murdered by his brother, who is now kind. This is the beginning of Hamlet’s spiral out of control and his attempt at gaining more control. His fathers spirit’s request to kill the king, Claudius, forced Hamlet to consider whether he wanted to ultimately control the fate of another persons life. Hamlet was essentilly stuck between a rock and a hard place; the hard place being staying loyal to his father’s request, and the hard place being staying loyal to his Christian faith and providence. At this point in the play, it is hard to tell what Hamlet will do. 

Hamlet’s action intensify when he takes control over his mothers actions and forces her to promise not to tell Claudius that he’s feigning madness. Later, Hamlet, feeling unfulfilled at having not killed the King yet, instead knowingly kills his childhood friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. This is the point in the play where we see Hamlet utilizing the most control over his life and others.

When Hamlet discovers the skull of Yorick, his childhood caretaker, randomly in the graveyard he realizes the uncertainty of life. It is here that he understands it is no other’s choice but God’s to seal someones fate. Up until this point, Shakespeare has toyed with Hamlet’s internal conflict. Whether he will or will not ultimately control the fate of his life and his uncles is not know until the near end of the play, when he admits to Horatio his acceptance of death. It is here that we learn Hamlet essentially chooses to stay loyal to his Christian faith and providence than follow his fathers spirit’s request. After his duel with Laertes, near death, Hamlet gives up the kingdom to Fortinbras, his final act of letting go of his control.

As seen through these various scenes in Hamlet, the question of whether Hamlet will ever give up control or not is difficult to follow. However, Shakespeare’s overall message is made clear by his making Hamlet indecisive. It demonstrates that all people are given the choice to take matters into their own hands or let whoever controls the world do it, and Hamlet’s ultimate decision shows Shakespeare’s view that fate is not up to the average human.

3 comments:

  1. Helle,
    First off, sorry if I ever spell your name as “Hella.” I have been on the Internet too long. Second off, try to work towards getting your point across faster. Just like we, the writers, are on a time limit, the readers are also trying to sift through lots of papers in little time, so the faster we can show them what our essays are about, the better. Your opening paragraph and statement is good, but I would really prune down your second paragraph and get straight into your claims and then use the plot and evidence to back up your claims. I feel like the amount of evidence you put in was only adequate, and really could have been fleshed out a bit more. Then again, I don’t quite agree that Hamlet’s need to control things is the main question of the play, so there is that. Either way, the more, well supported claims and evidence there is, the better, so long as everything still makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just a quick note before I get to analyzing is that you seem to be missing a lot of apostrophes throughout this, like, "fathers," "mothers," and "uncles." I don't really think that Hamlet was trying to control his multiple mothers or kill his various uncles, it changes the story a bit when you think about it that way. :) Up until your third body paragraph, I see a lot of plot summary going on, and I know that is what the prompt specifically said not to do, so be careful. Also, you seem only to get to the understanding of the work as a whole in your final paragraph. If you included spurts of the whole meaning throughout your essay, I think it will not only read and flow better, but you will also be able to avoid plot summary as well! But, of course, this is only our first attempt at writing these and that being said I think this is a very good and thorough post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Helle,
    I think the plot explanation is fine and necessary in order to answer this prompt, so I disagree with Sierra on that. But I do agree with her saying that you should have included more of your final point throughout the essay. Without a doubt the final paragraph was the strongest, which is good because it's the last thing the graders will have in their mind as they decide your grade. But I recommend simplifying your main idea to just a sentence and following closely a pattern of main idea sentence, prove it with evidence (quotes or plot), and link to thesis. You cant wander then! Good job, Helle. Your essay is written so that it's easy to read, apart from all the little punctuation errors that Sierra pointed out. :P Just blame auto-correct.

    ReplyDelete