Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Response to Course Material #5

This month, we basically continued on with our discussions about Hamlet. We came up with the main question: Will Hamlet ever relinquish control? and had six different scenes that correlated with that question. Picking six scenes was especially hard when there were so many that could be used to answer the question. Eventually, we picked the scenes where Hamlet lost control initially (the ghost scene), deliberated killing himself (to be or not to be), deliberated killing the King, talked with Horatio before the fight with Laertes, and died and gave away Elsinor to Fortinbras. These six scenes were the most important of the twelve or so that we came up with, and reflect Hamlet's insecurity with control. This activity really helped me write the last Open Prompt blog and understand Hamlet's main internal conflict.

Afterwards, we listed the many motifs seen in Hamlet, but most of them were already known to me. However, I didn't know how to split them up before we made the different categories like death, control, religion, and duality that helped connect the motifs and make it easier to remember them. Using our knowledge of the motifs, central questions, and conflicts in Hamlet we made the theme statement: Shakespeare's Hamlet suggests that one should be cautious of who one allows to be influenced by, because a lack of identity leads to immoral decisions. At first, I didn't like this theme statement because I didn't understand who had a lack of identity in the play. However, after some classmates helped me understand, we used the theme statement and different scenes from the play to see if they could work together to see if it could be used in a future essay.

The only thing other than Hamlet that we've been doing is the Collaborative Review for our upcoming exam. I think this was a pretty brilliant idea since everyone from each class can now read literally everything that we've learned this semester. It's like all the notes that I didn't take are now written out for me. My favorite part of the whole thing was comparing the terms and establishing what was different about them, such as anaphora and anadiplosis. My least favorite part was running out of ink while printing all forty-six pages of it... Nonetheless, I think this review is incredibly helpful, especially since each student was able to contribute and add their own thoughts and interpretations.

3 comments:

  1. Helle,
    I find it interesting that the six scenes that you choose to pick were almost directly linked to or are key plot points. I am currently taking an advanced screenwriting class at Michigan State, and one of the big things we talk about is structure, and how a movie, or any piece of media or literature, without structure is basically flawed. In movies, there is a very basic structure that all movies follow, of having three acts - derived from the structure of plays. And in the first act, the main character debates whether or not to do a certain thing that relates to the plot. Which is, kinda the entire plot of Hamlet over five acts… Did you also notice how close the motifs of Hamlet and the motifs in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern were?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This post is structured almost exactly as mine! Great minds think alike. ;) Very thorough work, though I would have liked (or rather I am telling you that Ms. Holmes would have liked) to see some connection to the things we've been doing in class to outside work, life, etc. I often find that this is the hardest part of these responses for me as well. Our class' theme statement certainly seemed lacking to me, and I think we just tried to include too many things into it, and thus, it lost all meaning. That is why for my Hamlet entry I decided to create my own theme statement! It may not have been the best, but I just saw how many of us were really unhappy with what we had come up with, so I thought it best not to use it. Side note: I cannot BELIEVE you printed off ALL FORTY SIX pages of that review! You are crazy! Did it help you out on the exam??

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Helle,
    The six scenes you chose are really interesting! My hour went in an entirely different direction, and honestly I just don't get the whole "Will Hamlet relinquish control?" question. In this post you explained it a little bit, like Hamlet is questioning if he should take control of others around him? I'm just not quite understanding how that would serve as the central question. Will he relinquish? Well, did he ever have it? And getting it in the first place is a crucial part... I don't know. Maybe I would have to have been in your hour and hearing the original discussion to get it. But I do like the scenes you picked out to accompany the idea. It's very interesting. And Helle, you should've printed it at school. If you want to avoid the disapproving look of the librarian as you stand at the printer for five minute going through entire ink cartridges, I think you could've printed it in the lab. I mean hey, your parents probably pay taxes, so you're entitled to some paper and ink. Right?

    ReplyDelete