Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading #2


For my second close reading, I read an article regarding the adoption services of today’s America, specifically the faith-based ones. The author used language, syntax, and details to get their point across regarding the types of adoption services in the United States right now.

Starting off the article, the author writes clearly and concisely that he/she believes religious-affiliated adoption services should be allowed to practice their occupation how they see fit, without intervention from the state government. The language conveyed in this first sentence already tells me how the author feels about the situation, as well as how strongly they feel about it. He/she used a short, to-the-point sentence to get their opinion across and nothing else, showing they want to set up their argument right away. However, most of the author’s language seems to be compromising and defensive. He/she says, “In the case of Catholic agencies, that means not working with unmarried couples. But there are agencies that do work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples, including some that are faith based” showing the author’s want for appealing to everyone that has a part in the situation. He/she mentions that some of the agencies that work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples are faith based, demonstrating the author’s defense of religion, trying to show that faith based agencies aren’t as bad as everyone seems to think.

Next, the author’s use of syntax is limited, but worthy of covering. He/she uses short, concise statements throughout the article to force a thought or opinion into the readers’ heads. After stating the Department of Human Services were hopeful of an agreement between them and the committee of a faith based agency, the author said “They should work toward that” again making it clear what he/she believes, by use of a short, forceful sentence.

The author’s included details are what help he/she get their point across the best. Mentioning that some faith based agencies do in fact work with unmarried couples and same-sex couples may convince some of those people to reconsider disliking those types of agencies. Also, by telling the readers that “the state money isn’t providing profits for religious organizations; it’s spent on services for the children”, the author is allowing the reader to consider that maybe a religious affiliated organization for adoption may not be too bad. The author’s use of these details is to convince the non-religious side of the situation that faith based agencies aren’t actually as evil as people make them out to be.

To conclude, I found this article especially interesting to read. I didn’t know so many adoption agencies practiced faith, but I believe the author had many good points to make regarding the situation. This may have to do with his/her good use of language, syntax, and detail, that succeeded in making me think more about the subject.

6 comments:

  1. Helle,
    Yet another fine piece of writing. Good work. I loved the way you structured your response. A thesis, three body paragraphs, and a conclusion. It made it very easy for me to follow along. One thing I noticed right off the bat is that you didn't include a link to the article. You may want to do this so Ms. Holmes doesn't mark you down:) Another thing you could fix up is the beginning of the second paragraph. You note that diction is used to create the authors meaning, however, I would like to know what specific diction clued you on the authors message. What examples can you pull from the article? Other than that your response was fabulous. In your second body paragraphs you use great textual evidence to support your claims. All in all, your structure really made this response shine. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Alex--Your analysis here is not very accurate, I'm afraid. It's true that there are some strong qualities to this piece, and you're right to say so. But as a peer reviewer, you need to put careful thought into pointing out areas where your peer needs to do some work on a piece, too--and that's where you're struggling, here. Have a look at the peer comments that follow yours and at my comments, below.

      Delete
  2. Helle,

    Great job on connecting DIDLS to how the author conveyed her theme/message on faith-based adoption agencies. Something I noticed in particular about your post is the persuasive writing techniques you used. Although your syntax paragraph is pretty short and, in my opinion, a point you didn't need to cover since you already stated the same point in the language paragraph, your topic sentence, "the author’s use of syntax is limited, but worthy of covering" addresses the counterargument (too little evidence for syntax) and refutes it with "but worthy of covering". Your paragraph on language is awesome - really spot on. Great points and examples. In your details paragraph, you could emphasize that the author truly focused on agencies helping same-sex or unmarried couples - right now, the paragraph is just restating the authors point. But it still was a strong, persuasive paragraph. My main critique is with your syntax paragraph. You didn't provide a link to the article so I can't say for sure, but I bet the author employed more syntax than just "short, concise statements". You also already mentioned this point in your paragraph on language. Overall, though, great Close Reading post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Debra--actually, the para on language is a problem, because it's not actually discussing language. It's discussion syntax, tone, and detail.

      Delete
  3. Hello Helle,

    Well, to start off, I would like to have a link to the mentioned article. Although it is interesting to read your well-written blog entry, it would also be helpful to refer to things that you mentioned (plus, I think Ms Holmes asks for us to provide the link). Although your statements and arguments are well constructed, there are some things I would like to point out. You seem to say the same thing twice. In your second paragraph you mention that the author's use of "a short, to the point sentence" was useful in setting up the position. However, in your third paragraph, you say pretty much the exact same sentence: "he/ she uses short concise statements...to force a thought or opinion into the readers' head." I wouldn't have been too worried about the repetition if it wasn't for the end of the paragraph where you say "making it clear what he/ she believes, by use of of short, forceful sentence." So what are the short sentences for? To force an opinion on someone or to illustrate, with force, one's own opinion. A small, but significant difference when explaining your analysis.
    I was wondering if the article implied that people see faith based agencies as evil, or if that was your own personal opinion on other people. If it was implied in the article, you could go in depth with how the article set up this. Good work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Helle--Your Sept entry was a little sloppy in some of its details, but generally a solid analysis. This piece has more serious issues. There is no link, (which your peer reviewers have pointed out, of course,) and you don't have sufficient evidence in your syntax paragraph. Your language para is not really about language. And overall, the piece just doesn't have much of a thesis, as Andrew has pointed out.

    ReplyDelete