Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt p.1

2003 Question 3

Student A: This particular student starts off wonderfully. The writer immediately makes a claim that The Great Gatsby is a tragedy, at first throwing me off, since I never read the book that way. But, he/she proceeded to give evidence in all body paragraphs that proved Gatsby himself to be a tragic character. Using a good amount of quotes (not too little, not too many), he/she demonstrated knowledge of the meaning of the quotes by making a claim, warranting it, and then giving evidence. In his/her third paragraph, he/she wrote very eloquently about the death of Gatsby and the repercussions it had. He/she says, "as a tragic figure, [Gatsby's] character flaws cause the undoing of others" giving ample understanding of what it means to be a tragic character, and also what the tragic character typically does to other characters in a novel. He/she came full circle as well, discussing the roaring 20s and Gatsby's similarity to them in the beginning, and then discussing Gatsby's and 20s eventual demise. Using excellent diction, syntax, and imagery, this student paints a picture in my head about The Great Gatsby and it's deeper meaning that I never saw when I read it. Overall, this essay was very good. I would give it an 9/9.

Student B: Student B also starts off well, despite starting her introduction with a quote by someone else.  However, she (her handwriting looks really girly) has an otherwise very strong introduction that clearly states what she will be talking about in her following paragraphs. However, reading her first main argument, I couldn't get a sense of what point she was trying to make. She explained, very well, the story of King Leon and his three daughters, however, never fully described why King Leon was a tragic character until the beginning of her last paragraph. To me, this isn't a very good writing technique if someone is trying to explain something, because for the whole reading, I was just trying to understand what she was talking about. Although, it did come all together in the end, and for that, this essay was pretty good. Her syntax was what made the essay most easily comprehendible. By repeating words and phrases that emphasized King Leon's overly prideful and egotistical personality, she made it clear (eventually), why King Leon was a tragic character. I'd say this essay got about a 7/9.

Student C: This student does not get off to a good start. Her (I'm assuming yet again because of handwriting) introduction was barely formed, and there was no thesis statement that explained what she would write about in her following paragraphs. Her sentences are choppy, by ending them too early. "The novel takes place on the mental ward of a hospital.  A ward run by the strict & watchful eye of Nurse Ratched, or Big Nurse." Firstly, "on the mental ward" doesn't make sense. Secondly, she should have taken "A ward" out and added a comma after "hospital", making that sentence much easier to read. She proceeds to discuss the main character, McMurphy (apparently the tragic hero) and his tragic flaw (being unable to conform) however, gives no evidence as to why that is his tragic flaw, or what happened in the book to make Nurse Ratched kill him. This lead me to be incredibly confused, but even more confusing was how the student continued writing about the climax of the play, after she had said McMurphy died. Her essay is unorganized and predictable, and her language is unsophisticated. I honestly would give it a 3/9 or lower.

3 comments:

  1. Helle,
    Good analysis of your selected students essays. For student 1, you noted that the writer uses warrants, claims, and evidence to support her argument, a fundamental piece of doing well on the Open Prompt essay. You also did a good job quoting the student and describing exactly what it was she did well, including the usage of imagery, diction, and syntax.
    Student 2: Good notations on the strong introduction/thesis. You noted the fogginess of the writing, accounting for the score 7/9. This seems to be a spot on analysis of this essay. P.S I liked your assumption due to "girly handwriting."
    Student 3: You started off noting the lack of structure, the poor writing, and the overall lack of analysis. I too, would have given this student a 3/9. This seems fair, and exactly what this student deserves.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Helle,
    Great job with your analysis of student responses to the Open Prompt. You did a good job on touching on the students' use of direct evidence and insight. Your first two analyses are pretty strong, although you could've mentioned more about how well/badly the student's responses tied to the prompt. In your third analysis (the 3/9), you need to address more about the author's problems with plot summary v. analysis, lack of specific support, etc. as noted in the AP essay rubric in the AP Lit files. Although you made good points on the author's composition errors, this shouldn't be the main focus of your analysis. Lastly, I don't think it's required, but it might be helpful to address some points made by traditional graders in your analyses, i.e. if you agree or disagree with what they say. Overall, great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Helle,
    My opinion of open prompt response blogs are that they are ways on how we can learn to write essays in the upcoming AP test. By analyzing student responses, we can see what makes a good essay successful, and thus use similar techniques to augment our own essays. We are not merely grading essays: we are learning from them.
    And you do a stellar job a dissecting the student essays and showcasing the flaws and strengths of each. The Student A analysis lists how the student uses diction, syntax, and imagery to answer the prompt, important tools to construct an essay. You even inserted an example to support your analysis. However, I find the Student B analysis lacking. You could say that you just had no idea what the student was writing, but I don't think that is very acceptable. Why does the student make no sense, there has to be a reason. What did the student get wrong? What could have been done to construct a better essay?.The last analysis was better, stating what the student did wrong, and an analysis of the flaws which we could avoid. The only problem I have is that you momentarily get distracted by specific grammatical errors, and not the center purpose and direction of the essay.

    ReplyDelete