Before starting Ceremony, we were finishing up Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. My class (maybe it was just me) had a hard time really getting the play. We bounced all the likely ideas, such as that maybe Stoppard was just mocking those literature analysts that look way too deeply into books and other works. Or he could have been pondering the idea of life and death and people's reaction toward the whole idea during their lifetime. Class discussions were entertaining, to say the least, but I found that I learned the most from reading various lectures and articles about the play. Specifically, the postmodern lecture was the most interesting analysis of any play we've read thus far. I learned a lot of new words (e.g. pastiche, différance, and epistemological) and I came to be more easily articulate about my understanding of the play. Personally, I thought the main undertone of the play was a commentary on life and death. Life, Stoppard infers, is confusing and filled with choices that most of us probably don't want to make or maybe don't even know how to make, like Ros and Guil. The only possible ending for life is death, Stoppard says, and "time is its only measure" (p 72).
Between discussing Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead and starting Ceremony we practiced different types of writing activities. We had intro/structure practice, where we had to write two of our own made open prompts and then write the structure of an essay for two peers own written open prompts. Writing the prompts was really fun for me. I tried to make it a balance between an academic and fun essay to write, appealing to both the intellectual and creative writer. Trying to find a good prompt to respond to was hard at first, but a lot of AP students are really creative with theirs too so I found a couple in no time.
To start off Ceremony, we had to go through the Tayo's World powerpoint, Silko's essays, and critical lenses prezi. The powerpoint was a good introduction to the novel, explaining the Pueblo culture so that while reading I didn't have to put my book down to look up what Silko was referencing. The critical lenses prezi was also informative, but I've already studied the different types of lenses, so it was basically a reminder for me. My favorite of the three to study was Silko's essays because she's just such a good writer. She's very enticing, almost manipulative at times, but always keeps me wanting to learn more. History books explain Native culture in the most basic terms, as simply and shortly as possible, but Silko writes with love for her people and shows rather than tells.
Reading Ceremony has been a pleasure as well. Finally, A BOOK. I've been waiting for this all year. Don't get me wrong, I've enjoyed each play we've read this year, but there's a certain depth I get from books that I can't get from plays. The recurring remarks about white people gets me a little defensive at times, but I remind myself that I'm a second generation American and Silko isn't really targeting my ancestors. Silko is amazing at pulling the reader in and realistically making me feel like I'm Tayo and I've just come back from the war. The characters, plot, and tense were all confusing at first, but after reading the beginning twice, things became less foggy. Whoever wrote the family tree on the board in class really helped me out too.
Finally, after discussing Ceremony, we began to discuss the various critical lenses and how each applied to the plays we read earlier this year. Regarding The American Dream, we touched on feminism, looking at quotes like "What a masculine Daddy!" and how that demonstrated Albee's possible scorn for women. Looking into Albee's past, we discussed the idea that maybe he regarded his adoptive mother as domineering and hateful toward his sexuality, whereas his adoptive father was more loving, but emasculated and dominated by his wife, reflecting Mommy and Daddy from the novel. We also discussed the possibility that the Young Man was a reflection of Albee himself. From a historic lens, one could make the connection between the time The American Dream was written and the materialistic manners of the new generation of America at the same time. For Death of a Salesman, we also looked at Arthur Miller's background to see the connection between the play and his life. I remember reading that Miller had an uncle like Willy; unable to recognize his own failure, but still convinced he's a success. A historic lens would point at the fact that at the time the play was written, America was essentially a flytrap for commercialism and big business, which is reflected in the play. From a colonial (or post colonian? Post modern colonial? I can't remember...) lens, Miller's references to the jungle can be seen as an insinuation that Americans are imperialist and domineering. We came up with two keys to success that Miller might have been outlining in his play. One can either lie, cheat, and steal to the top, or be honest and hardworking. Regarding the critical lenses as a whole, I'm a little confused as to why we looked at them so late in the year. I know Ms. Holmes was talking about it in class, but I think I missed the point. Why didn't we look at them while we were reading? Which do you guys think would have been better, looking at them in the beginning of the year or at the end like we are now?
Helle--What I said in class was that we looked at the lenses near the end of the year for two reasons: the AP test is all formalism and you need none of the other lenses at all on this test, and our discussion of the other lenses was intended as a lead-in to a period of review and synthesis of the previously read works. Also, remember that "infer" means to "deduce from evidence." In the context above, you mean "imply."
ReplyDeleteHelle,
ReplyDeleteI think the interesting part about the critical lenses is that we naturally talk about aspects of them while discussing. Feminism is the example I always think of. We looked at both The American Dream and Hamlet through the feminist lense by questioning the male and female roles of the characters. I think having the full understanding of the lenses helped for trying to look at Ceremony from a different viewpoint.
The Ros and Guil discussion was one of my favorites all year for the class. I think it forces a lot of discussion because there is no easy answer to the play like Hamlet and Death of a Salesman have.
Great post!
Good post. It's interesting that you said you liked the postmodern article regarding Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, because everyone in my hour seemed to really dislike it. I, like you, thought it made some very good points, though I did agree with my classmates that it was too lecturing and had a rather condescending tone.
ReplyDeleteI, contrary to you, would've been content to keep reading plays, and I tend to like them more than books. I was actually a little disappointed when we finally left the world of theater after we finished Stoppard and began Ceremony.
I'd venture as far as to say that going back and looking through old works with different critical lenses and the connecting them to each other was one of my favorite parts of the course this year. I really enjoyed going back and looking at works like The American Dream again, considering with a fresh mind after not having really thought about it too deeply in several months.