Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt p.1

2004 Question 2

Student A demonstrates an ability to read between the lines of Henry James' "The Pupil" as shown through his understanding of the irony and mockery displayed in the piece. He separately discusses the three characters, Mrs. Moreen, Morgan Moreen, and Pemberton, making for a good, organized essay. The student avoids mere plot summary by giving examples from the text and then explaining them to fit his thesis. Though this student's essay was not error free (there were quite a few grammatical and spelling errors), his understanding of the short story and ability to analyze it was clear. He was awarded with an 8; I would award him with a 9.

Student B does not start her essay very well. Her thesis, "By closely examing "The Pupil" one can see that Henry James creates contrasting characters that work together to create a story" literally doesn't say anything. What will she be discussing in her later paragraphs? What does it mean they "work together to create a story"? In her first paragraph, she compares Mrs. Moreen to Pemberton. She makes the claim that "one gets a sense of [carelessness] through Pemberton's opening thoughts regarding money" but never shares what his thought was, leaving me unable to relate to the sense of carelessness. Although this doesn't bode well for her score, in general, she shows an understanding of James' message of the social structure in the time period. Her language goes in circles at times, but her references to the text allow us to realize her basic analytic ability. She was given a 6, however I would give her a 5.

Student C shows a very low level of analytical skill. Rather than write about tone, diction, or other literary tools used by writers, the student concentrates more on how she felt about the piece. "My favorite part of this reading was the author's characterization" is simply not what one says in an analytical essay. However, she does continue on to comment on the characters character and how it's shown through their actions. She makes a lame comment on the "vibrant and believable" imagery of the piece as well, showing a basic understanding of DIDLS and the meaning they bring to a work of literature. Despite this, the bulk of the essay amplified the student's weak ability to read, analyze, and comment on "The Pupil".

3 comments:

  1. Hi Helle,

    Great job in hitting key points in scoring an essay -- plot summary vs. analysis, composition, and support. It'd be helpful next time if you provided the prompt (just a little thing). Did the AP readers give the first response an eight because of the grammatical and spelling errors or was it for another reason? It'd be great if you could discuss this next time you disagree with an AP reader's score. I liked how you touched on thesis with each response, but I think what you could work on is getting the overall picture of each response. For example, in your second response, you just hit on the thesis and one example. How did the student do with their other claims? Overall, did the essay have sufficient support and analysis? Otherwise, solid analysis on these Open Prompt responses.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Helle,

    It seems that you did a closed prompt (or am I wrong? I still don't know). I think they are the 3rd prompt every year. I hope I'm wrong so you can get credit for this. As for your critiques, nice job. You addressed main issues and how the essay accompanied the thesis of each essay. However, I would do more to give a variety of small issues and give specific examples in the critiques. Giving an example of the grammatical errors in essay 1 would have made your argument stronger, and helped readers understand the extent the grammatical errors had on the essay as a whole. You had more direct examples in the second essay (nice job with that) but you could add a little more with explaining what "her language goes in circles at times" means. Your third critique had some very valuable opinions. I feel that with an essay at this level, you could mention the student's grammar and word choice, if it helped the student or harmed her even more. I think overall your analysis of the essays are really good, just a few more details could make it even stronger.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your analysis was excellent, and I really liked that you compared your assessment of the papers to that of the AP readers and gave all of the essays scores yourself. You used plenty of textual evidence so the only advice I have is to maybe include the prompt next time, but other than that this is solid. Great work.

    ReplyDelete