Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading #4


Democrats and Republicans have been angrily disputing the new Affordable Care Act for months now. Using diction, language, and details, Scott Brown in his article, Stunning hypocrisy from Democrats in wake of ObamaCare’s broken promises leaves no room for debate as to whose side he’s on amidst this conflict.
           
The first words one see this article are “hypocrisy” and “double standards”. Given the name of the article, these words are clearly placed in the very beginning to paint a picture in the readers mind right away about Obamacare and its Democratic supporters. Brown leads off with “as the new law implodes before our eyes” before reciting the details of Obamacare’s shaky rollout. By choosing to say the law “imploded”, Brown is attempting to make us picture an unstable disaster that collapsed upon itself because of its numerous flaws. Brown makes it really clear what he thinks when he blatantly calls the law a “catastrophe” – an intense word choice that we often identify with events such as hurricane Katrina. The diction employed by Scott Brown is helpful in identifying his bias toward the Affordable Care Act. 

Another helpful tool is Brown’s language. After discussing the unfortunate cases of some Americans’ issues with ObamaCare, he says some people “all of a sudden find themselves out of luck.” This language seems to make the misfortune of millions of Americans extremely casual. By making it seem so casual, Brown is actually mocking the Democrats and their apparent apathy toward those Americans who have lost their health plan. When discussing Democrat’s refusal to compromise with Republicans, Brown says they’re “stubbornly digging in their heels”, creating a mocking tone. The language of this sentence makes us image little, spoiled bratty kids who won’t listen to their parents until they get what they want. Brown’s language throughout the article is mocking, intended to make the reader disgusted by Democrats and their childish actions.

The third tool Brown uses to emphasize his point that ObamaCare is a disaster is detail. At the beginning of the article, he says Americans were “repeatedly assured by President Obama” that they could keep their health plan if they wanted to. With the detail that the President “repeatedly” said this, when Brown later mentions that millions of Americans have actually lost their plans, the reader is meant to get mad, as though they’ve been let down “repeatedly”. He continues to say “approximately 5 million people [are] expected to lose their current plan and millions more [are] to follow.” With the detail that “millions more [are] to follow” the reader is being emotionally appealed to. They’re made to fear, “am I next?” in turn making the reader unsure of their feelings about ObamaCare. The details used by Brown are clearly an attempt at changing the reader’s initial thoughts about the law.

Using diction, language, and details, Brown successfully makes it difficult to think positively about the new Affordable Care Act passed by the Obama Administration. However, with their use, it is also difficult not to see his clear bias and hatred toward ObamaCare and it’s supporters.

http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2013/12/03/stunning-hypocrisy-from-democrats-in-wake-obamacare-broken-promises/?intcmp=trending

*On a side note, could someone shed some light as to where to put any punctuation following a quote? The way I did it in this article seems a little off to me.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Helle,

    Great job with your blog post! Overall, nice use of examples and textual evidence to connect DIDLS with the author's intentions of showing us the Democrats' hypocrisy. For your analysis on diction, be careful not to stray into imagery -- this referring specifically to your analysis of the word "imploded". You have the same problem with your language paragraph in tying his use of, "stubbornly digging in his heels", to imagery and not language. Now that I'm peer reviewing your close reading, I feel like I don't have the best handle on the the lines between each aspect of DIDLS. But I don't think you did details quite right either. Your analysis of "repeatedly" seems more like diction, since you're just talking about a single word which wasn't used repeatedly in the article. As for the punctuation after a quote, I'm not an expert, but I think you have it spot on. If the quote ends a sentence, then the punctuation goes before. If the quote is in the middle of a sentence, the punctuation goes after. The only punctuation I'm unsure of is the "am I right?". It would seem to follow the question mark with another punctuation (in my case and in yours), but it also seems weird to just end with a question mark. Not too sure about that one. Anyway, great post, Helle!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Helle,

    That's a pretty persuasive essay you wrote there, nice! I would recommend that you add imagery in your next essay. The word "imploded" could be disputed, however, the explanation you have after the word makes it a great example for imagery. If anything, I think moving the "repeatedly" section into diction and adding the example from the first paragraph from your article of "disgust" and "infuriate" would make the essay a bit more clear. You also reference imagery in your next paragraph with the "stubbornly digging in their heels" as an "image [of] little, spoiled bratty kids who won’t listen to their parents until they get what they want". You have great examples here, but I don't think they are all labeled correctly. You seem to explain imagery flawlessly so definitely use that next time! Just try to avoid saying "creates the image of" when you don't want it to represent imagery. I'm not actually quite sure how to do correct quotations either, I'm always getting mixed up between english and spanish, so sorry can't help there. Overall, very nice job on the article! Your introduction and conclusion were very clear and it had a strong theme. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good work! I thought your post was very good and thought that you did a great job at showing how the author used DIDLS. I have to agree with Debra though that "repeatedly" probably belongs more in diction than it does in details, but I thought that all of the other examples you cited worked (good job on using lots of textual evidence too). And I'm pretty sure you punctuated the quotes correctly.

    ReplyDelete